[pp.int.general] ACTA declaration

Boris Turovskiy tourovski at gmail.com
Fri Jul 9 10:34:18 CEST 2010


On 09.07.2010 10:19, Maxime Rouquet wrote:
> A car is an object. If you drive your car, nobody else can. It is your 
> property. You are free to share it with people or to keep it for 
> yourself, but if you let someone else drive it, you cannot use it in 
> the meantime.
>
> A song is not physical. You can sing it while a thousand people sing 
> it at the same time. You can easily make a digital copy of a music 
> without stealing anything from the people who have the original. You 
> may have rights on your song, but property is a nonsense.
Guys, I don't have either time or will to explain to every single one of 
you what non-scarcety is and why it is not the only notion of property 
and what notions of property exist and WHAT THE FUCK WE'RE TALKING ABOUT!!!!

So, Maxime, Fyodor, and how the f--k you are called, please, try to lift 
the level of the discussion from the kindergarten idea which seems to be 
flourishing among both friend and opponent.
Read some books. Try some Googling.
This level of discussion made me despair in the Pirate movement once. 
Don't make me despair the second time, for I'm rather dedicated to that 
movement now, and you bullshitting us will have severe problems.

Read some books. Try some Google. Don't fuck around before you can 
answer the top 10 of your "critical" questions yourself. Don't use the 
Force, Luke, use the brain.

Best,
B.


More information about the pp.international.general mailing list